By Rob Cooney (@EMEducation)
Wild Problems: A Guide to the Decisions That Define Us
by Russ Roberts
The need for certainty is the greatest disease the mind faces – Robert Greene, Mastery
In “Wild Problems: A Guide to the Decisions That Define Us,” Russ Roberts delves into the intricate landscape of human decision-making, particularly focusing on the choices that shape our lives in profound ways. These are decisions that where knowing which path to take is unknowable (getting married, having children) yet the results of these decisions shape who we might become. As an economist renowned for his insights into human behavior, Roberts challenges the conventional reliance on rational choice theory and cost-benefit analysis. He introduces the concept of “wild problems”—complex decisions where data is insufficient, outcomes are unpredictable, and traditional analytical tools fall short.
Roberts begins his exploration into Wild Problems by critiquing the overemphasis on rationality in decision-making processes using Darwin’s personal journals and decisions about marriage to illustrate the concepts. While cost-benefit analysis is effective for straightforward choices, it is inadequate for decisions involving significant personal change or moral considerations. For instance, choices about marriage, career paths, or having children cannot be distilled into simple pros and cons. These decisions are laden with emotions, unknown variables, and personal values that resist quantification.
The book underscores the inevitability of uncertainty in life’s most significant choices. Roberts encourages readers to accept that not all variables can be known or controlled. He warns against the paralysis that can result from overanalyzing and striving for certainty. Instead, embracing uncertainty can lead to more authentic and fulfilling decisions, opening doors to possibilities that rigid analysis might overlook.
Also central to wild problems is the need to recognize that these decisions are deeply intertwined with our sense of self. Decisions such as starting a family, changing careers, or taking on leadership roles shape who we are and how we perceive ourselves. Roberts advocates for introspection to understand one’s core values and how they should guide decision-making. Related to this is the need to move away from the economic principle of utility maximization, Roberts proposes a more holistic approach to decision-making. He suggests evaluating choices based on how they contribute to one’s life’s story and personal growth, rather than solely on material gains or losses. This perspective encourages individuals to consider long-term fulfillment over immediate gratification, though we all know how difficult this can be. “Wild Problems” offers a deep exploration of the challenges inherent in making life’s most significant decisions. Russ Roberts invites us to step beyond traditional analytical frameworks and consider deeper aspects of choice, including uncertainty, personal values, and purpose. As an educator, these themes resonate with me when considering some of the more challenging decisions I’ve made. Is this learner ready for independent practice? Should I stay or pursue a new career opportunity? How do I help learners “see” how I made this decision? For faculty members in health professions education, embracing the insights from this book can lead to more thoughtful decision-making, enrich the educational experience for students, and ultimately contribute to the advancement of the health professions.
The views and opinions expressed in this post are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the official policy or position of The University of Ottawa. For more details on our site disclaimers, please see our ‘About’ page